Reviewer Checklist

The following checklist should be submitted with your review:

• One short paragraph to sum up the manuscript.
• Is the manuscript represent a novel adds to science.
• All comments are clearly defined to the corresponding section.
• Is the manuscript followed the instructions in the guide for authors and written in the journal template.

• Does the article have short and concise title that accurately reflect the presented work.
• Is the abstract complete and fall in logic structure of introduction, aim, methodology, results and conclusion.

• Does the article answer all the objective questions.
• Check the references are written according to the journal specifications.
• Check the work was not published on any other places.

Recommendation

Final recommendation should be one of the following:

• Reject (with proper justification)
• Accept without revision
• Accept with Revision – major or minor (clear explanation for the type of the revision)